Ronwen Blamed For Mexico Blunder

A panel of 2026 FIFA World Cup pundits have questioned whether Bafana Bafana captain Ronwen Williams should shoulder some of the blame for the opening goal conceded against Mexico.

Check Out: SA Omitted From African Sides Expected To 'Go Far' At WC

South Africa struggled to settle into the contest and found themselves behind after just 10 minutes when an attempt to play out from the back went wrong.

Yaya Sithole was dispossessed on the edge of his own penalty area, allowing Julian Quinones to burst forward before slotting the ball through the legs of Williams to hand the hosts the lead.

Moments before the goal, Williams had played the ball into Sithole, who was immediately placed under intense pressure by the Mexican press.

Speaking on CBS Golazo after the match, former Major League Soccer star Ian Paul argued that the goalkeeper should never have put his teammate in such a difficult position.

"You're the goalkeeper, you see the whole field in front of you, you have your defensive midfielder and you know what's around that defensive midfielder," Paul said.

"For that first goal in particular, he decided to pass it straight to his defensive midfielder and his defensive midfielder could not turn because he had a player in front of him, could not go to the left because he had a player there, could not go to the right because he had a player there.

"Now to me that's ridiculous if there's no communication because you can't hear each other inside that stadium with 95 or whatever thousand fans inside, you can't hear a thing."

Why Did The Pundits Criticise South Africa's Build-Up Play?

Paul went on to suggest that Williams unnecessarily exposed his teammate to danger in a high-risk area of the pitch.

"Like it's so ridiculous you've been in that occasion as well, especially in Africa, I can't even begin to imagine how loud that is.

"Why put your player in that position? So as much as you can say great well done, maybe we can also say that the goalkeeper was at fault and that's probably the reason why they were behind."

However, fellow pundit Michael Lahoud disagreed with Paul's assessment and instead placed the responsibility on Sithole.

The former Sierra Leone international argued that receiving the ball under pressure is part of a defensive midfielder's role and that Sithole should have handled the situation better.

"But it's not on the goalkeeper for me, Ian. It has to be on the midfielder," Lahoud said.

"I was stopped by this and I was stopped by a manager who won the World Cup and he said as a defensive midfielder it is your job to demand the ball, to want the ball at the top of the box.

"That's the whole reason why Sithole's in there."

When asked whether he would have wanted the ball in that situation, Lahoud gave a firm response.

Check Out: Czech Star Eyes Three 'Needed' Points Against Bafana

Regardless of where the blame lies, Bafana Bafana will be eager to cut out such costly mistakes as they look to bounce back from their opening defeat and keep their hopes of reaching the knockout stages alive.